I normally give my honest feedback so here it is:
1) Ace - superb vid as usual, needs my platinum addition footage for total pwnage, lol
2) BladeX - You showed the most improvement I think I have seen from 1 vid to another...for Youtube the quality wasn't that bad which means a AMV.org one would havemade it look much better
Song choice was very nice and fit but you could have worked out a bit more of the story of it...seemed the vid was still a bit too much all over the place. Also the ending still needs some work but you are getting much better so hang in there!!!
3) Xelhes...I was disappointed in this one, I have seen much better work from you...not in the technical aspect but the story was just not there...that is a problem with using footage from multiple series...it hurts the vid 99% of the time more than it helps. Very few multi song/series vids out there that are really good. It reduces footage for each one to a low amount already low due to the length of the song...makes it tell too little of any of them to do you any good. Now I did really like your intro/ending theme more than I liked the vid...what was that song? Also the FFXIII footage was all you needed IMO, going to be one bad game