Quote:
Originally Posted by divine_punishment  Ed may be stronger as an alchemist, but Alphonse is an aluminum can. What's the worst that could happen to him? A dent? They may be brothers and brothers certainly argue, but I don't think that they would BATTLE . . . |
The worst that could happen to him, would obviously be for him to be trans-mutated. There is also the possibility that some weapons can puncture, or pass through him. He may be made of metal, but he is not impregnable.
Edward transforms his metal blades from his metal arm, which is of a much stronger metal than Alphonse's armor. Forget about the fact that Edward can transform into a cannon.
However, as we all keep saying they would not fight to such a level, so it's almost a mute point.
However, the question is asking IF (that's if) they did, who would win.