View Single Post
Old May 03, 2008, 03:40 AM   #11 (permalink)
cantsenditback
10 Highscores
byakugan
 
cantsenditback's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: France, Scotland, Ireland, Malaysia
Posts: 684
Thanks: 7
Thanked 36 Times in 35 Posts
cantsenditback is off to a good start
Credits: 15,195
Re: T.V. Shows as an Anime

Quote:
Originally Posted by Hantei16 View Post
MOST is definitely not the word for it, the western part of the world is getting much less anime...to some westerners it may look a lot but it's really a helluva lot less than what the east is getting. However the east(by east i mean far east) isn't really into shows like Buffy and other western titles out there, some love it but some just don't care. There are a few well-received ones here and there, like Heroes and Highlander tho....So if something like Buffy or Xena becomes adapted into anime, i wouldn't be surprised if it ends up successful but i wouldn't be surprised if it ends up as a total flop either.

If western shows doesn't really tickle the eastern taste that much, the same can be said for anime and the west.



It is a possibility but i don't think that Japan would Japanize something that is considered a B-show in Japan(or even Asia).



True, that's always the most likely thing to happen either way. Lots of Japanese titles have already been Americanized and vice versa, and what you've just said happens most of the time...think of GoLion and Dairugger XV which was westernized as Voltron(lions and Vehicles), both ended up having drastic makeovers...Same can be said for Japanized shows, think Spiderman, think Powerpuff Girls Z, and so on.

Another thing, if a western show becomes easternized(and vice-versa) do you think that it will appeal to the fans of its original region, and to the core fans of the original version? Looking back at history, i don't think so...Think Power Rangers(in its entirety), yes it did appeal to the west but eastern and hardcore fans of the Sentai(the kind of show from which PR was taken) were angry coz they thought the west destroyed it. The same can be said for Spiderman, the west and the comic fans thought it desecrated an icon. Look at the Asian horror flicks, they did american versions and the asians had negative reactions. Think Godzilla, Kamen Rider RX(americanized as Masked rider), etc., yadda yadda.

It's okay for a person to wish for an American show to have an Anime spinoff but when it comes to fruition i wouldn't be surprized if that person ends up in disappointment boulevard. Localization is one BIG obstacle....

American cartoon-Anime, Movie-Movie, Cartoon and Comic-Tokusatsu, Western Show-Anime, so on and so forth....It always comes packaged with gazillion tons of negativity.
True, one person who like the jap version of an anime may hate the american version of that show or the other way around. Like me, This is what i hate about the americans when they dubbed a jap anime, There may be some screen shot been cut or an unaired show that was an importand episode in the seires, it would be good to keep the original storyline and every episode and only dubbed the voices for the character and the name for that character, others may like both version of that particular anime. but everyone have a different view on that one anime and wheather they like both the jap or american version
__________________


This world is corrupt
Save tonight and fight the break of dawn
I am so alone, I got no one to talk to, please help me
Status: Offline
 
Reply With Quote