LenMiyata

Grumble Grumble Grumble

It now appears that the Japanese broadcasting networks and anime production studios are finally getting pissed off with the video piracy on YouTube, and are preparing to respond with legal action...

Japan group seeks YouTube copyright system - Yahoo! News

So the question has to be asked... Why hasn't YouTube done more to prevent video piracy, and with over 60% of YouTube video content having licensing issues, how long can YouTube can survivie (now that it has money to sue for) with it's current business model...

__________________

Hassun

I thought things would change when youtube was bought by "the Google".
Guess not.

__________________

Shu

i bet nothing will happen, youtube will just dump a bunch of vids if things get out of control

LenMiyata

Grumble Grumble Grumble
YouTube dumped 30,000 Japanese videos last month... this wasn't enough to satisfy the Japanese Publishing group... What they want is a mechanism to PREVENT the posting of copyrighted material, and it's not known if this is even possible....

__________________

Legend

Yeah from the way things look right now, it will seem that Google has bought a lemon. Unless they do something about it, they are going to lose a bunch. Without most of the pirated content on youtube, there isn't much that interests me personally.

__________________
Cheer up, sleepy jean.
Oh, what can it mean.
To a daydream believer
And a homecoming queen...yeahhhhhh

Flying Ace

I personally think that this will turn out just like Kazaa, Bearshare, Limewire, etc. These programs are quite illegal if you think about it, heck, it's just getting free songs that you should be paying for if you think about it. But I really don't think that anyone is going to be able to stop these programs from being able to share music. I think that this will be the same thing with youtube. I highly doubt that they're going to have to take off the videos or pay a fine or anything like that.

Silverskater145

Kazaa? Since when was YouTube illegal p2p software? Don't be silly. YouTube has merely been lazy in getting rid some of the copyrighted material.

I'm personally divided between the two ends of the spectrum on this issue. I can't understand myself how they've been getting away with this (although lawsuits should prevent any further continuation), but at the same time, I don't want any change. To be honest, I couldn't have caught up in Naruto without YouTube. I've watched Naruto from episodes 45 to 154 and ongoing for a month and a half now. Watching anime on YouTube is considerably faster than downloading, and convenient.

A weird motif that comes out through this story though, is the internet piracy problem. I wonder if people will begin to realize just how troublesome this has begun. Like I've told some of my friends before, YouTube can remove videos, but people will always put them back up. While YouTube should manage the website better and remove the copyrighted material with more vigor, you can only do so much against a society that demands to pirate any which way. At this point, piracy is a problem that cannot be stopped. For every Piracy group (whether it be a website or software) that gets shut down, two more will come up in it's place.

The fact that several companies had a problem with music videos on YouTube is a prime example of why pirating exists in the first place. If it doesn't benefit companies (in $), then they won't bother to benefit us. Music videos come on TV all the time, but it boggles my mind that they actually have a problem with the videos on YouTube. The only difference is, you watch what you want to watch, when you want to watch it. And of course big companies will have a problem with this. They want to mooch off more money, and that can't happen if you can get what you want, when you want. They want you to comply with their rules and standards, but as long as they exist, so will piracy.

Maybe YouTube and the Japanese can work up some sort of scheme. Like a special, paid membership that has permission to some, if not all the copyrighted anime (with higher quality maybe?).

__________________

Tano-kun

oh man, no way...are u serious?...youtube is so awesome it's gonna suck if it's taken away...

rockroc

this is gonna suck, that means no more anime, they're gonna delete Tenchi Muyo ahhh dam them, thats my favorite anime.

__________________
Fighting Game Fanatic, I owned Gill and I'll own you next. =D

Flying Ace

You're right, my point was just the same as yours though. It's not illegal software necessarily. But I've been hearing things like this about rom emulations as well, and yet, no one can prevent it. I have to admit I love youtube, and it'd be hard for me to keep up with my shows without it.

jaam0927

I dont think its "the end"... I mean yeah I could prolly cost some big bucks in legal disputes... but why would google pay, how much was it? 1.7 billion dollars? just to later lose a legal dispute and close it?
it is prolly trying to incorporate youtube to google video...
even with with google buying youtube, who do ppl expect that they control what is copy righted and what is not, I mean there is like a million ppl using youtube to host their videos, how are they going to go over that?
and for me, those companies shouldnt be "throwing the rock" at youtube, it is only a service, they should be focusing their attention to those that are uploading the videos, cuz they are the ones violating the copy right.
I think that google its gonna get away with it...

__________________