+ Reply to Thread
Results 1 to 7 of 7

Thread: Comcast Blocks Internet Traffic

  1. #1
    Witch Hunter GallComp may be famous one day GallComp may be famous one day GallComp's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2004
    Location
    Near Disneyland
    Posts
    944
    Thanks
    2
    Thanked 19 Times in 16 Posts

    Comcast Blocks Internet Traffic

    Now this is an interesting read I just found on yahoo news. I heard complaints on other web sites but I wasnt aware of the AP test...


    By PETER SVENSSON, AP Technology Writer

    NEW YORK - Comcast Corp. actively interferes with attempts by some of its high-speed Internet subscribers to share files online, a move that runs counter to the tradition of treating all types of Net traffic equally.

    The interference, which The Associated Press confirmed through nationwide tests, is the most drastic example yet of data discrimination by a U.S. Internet service provider. It involves company computers masquerading as those of its users.

    If widely applied by other ISPs, the technology Comcast is using would be a crippling blow to the BitTorrent, eDonkey and Gnutella file-sharing networks. While these are mainly known as sources of copyright music, software and movies, BitTorrent in particular is emerging as a legitimate tool for quickly disseminating legal content.

    The principle of equal treatment of traffic, called "Net Neutrality" by proponents, is not enshrined in law but supported by some regulations. Most of the debate around the issue has centered on tentative plans, now postponed, by large Internet carriers to offer preferential treatment of traffic from certain content providers for a fee.

    Comcast's interference, on the other hand, appears to be an aggressive way of managing its network to keep file-sharing traffic from swallowing too much bandwidth and affecting the Internet speeds of other subscribers.

    Comcast, the nation's largest cable TV operator and No. 2 Internet provider, would not specifically address the practice, but spokesman Charlie Douglas confirmed that it uses sophisticated methods to keep Net connections running smoothly.

    "Comcast does not block access to any applications, including BitTorrent," he said.

    Douglas would not specify what the company means by "access" — Comcast subscribers can download BitTorrent files without hindrance. Only uploads of complete files are blocked or delayed by the company, as indicated by AP tests.

    But with "peer-to-peer" technology, users exchange files with each other, and one person's upload is another's download. That means Comcast's blocking of certain uploads has repercussions in the global network of file sharers.

    Comcast's technology kicks in, though not consistently, when one BitTorrent user attempts to share a complete file with another user.

    Each PC gets a message invisible to the user that looks like it comes from the other computer, telling it to stop communicating. But neither message originated from the other computer — it comes from Comcast. If it were a telephone conversation, it would be like the operator breaking into the conversation, telling each talker in the voice of the other: "Sorry, I have to hang up. Good bye."

    Matthew Elvey, a Comcast subscriber in the San Francisco area who has noticed BitTorrent uploads being stifled, acknowledged that the company has the right to manage its network, but disapproves of the method, saying it appears to be deceptive.

    "There's the wrong way of going about that and the right way," said Elvey, who is a computer consultant.

    Comcast's interference affects all types of content, meaning that, for instance, an independent movie producer who wanted to distribute his work using BitTorrent and his Comcast connection could find that difficult or impossible — as would someone pirating music.

    Internet service providers have long complained about the vast amounts of traffic generated by a small number of subscribers who are avid users of file-sharing programs. Peer-to-peer applications account for between 50 percent and 90 percent of overall Internet traffic, according to a survey this year by ipoque GmbH, a German vendor of traffic-management equipment.

    "We have a responsibility to manage our network to ensure all our customers have the best broadband experience possible," Douglas said. "This means we use the latest technologies to manage our network to provide a quality experience for all Comcast subscribers."

    The practice of managing the flow of Internet data is known as "traffic shaping," and is already widespread among Internet service providers. It usually involves slowing down some forms of traffic, like file-sharing, while giving others priority. Other ISPs have attempted to block some file-sharing application by so-called "port filtering," but that method is easily circumvented and now largely ineffective.

    Comcast's approach to traffic shaping is different because of the drastic effect it has on one type of traffic — in some cases blocking it rather than slowing it down — and the method used, which is difficult to circumvent and involves the company falsifying network traffic.

    The "Net Neutrality" debate erupted in 2005, when AT&T Inc. suggested it would like to charge some Web companies more for preferential treatment of their traffic. Consumer advocates and Web heavyweights like Google Inc. and Amazon Inc. cried foul, saying it's a bedrock principle of the Internet that all traffic be treated equally.

    To get its acquisition of BellSouth Corp. approved by the Federal Communications Commission, AT&T agreed in late 2006 not to implement such plans or prioritize traffic based on its origin for two and a half years. However, it did not make any commitments not to prioritize traffic based on its type, which is what Comcast is doing.

    The FCC's stance on traffic shaping is not clear. A 2005 policy statement says that "consumers are entitled to run applications and services of their choice," but that principle is "subject to reasonable network management." Spokeswoman Mary Diamond would not elaborate.

    Free Press, a Washington-based public interest group that advocates Net Neutrality, opposes the kind of filtering applied by Comcast.

    "We don't believe that any Internet provider should be able to discriminate, block or impair their consumers ability to send or receive legal content over the Internet," said Free Press spokeswoman Jen Howard.

    Paul "Tony" Watson, a network security engineer at Google Inc. who has previously studied ways hackers could disrupt Internet traffic in manner similar to the method Comcast is using, said the cable company was probably acting within its legal rights.

    "It's their network and they can do what they want," said Watson. "My concern is the precedent. In the past, when people got an ISP connection, they were getting a connection to the Internet. The only determination was price and bandwidth. Now they're going to have to make much more complicated decisions such as price, bandwidth, and what services I can get over the Internet."

    Several companies have sprung up that rely on peer-to-peer technology, including BitTorrent Inc., founded by the creator of the BitTorrent software (which exists in several versions freely distributed by different groups and companies).

    Ashwin Navin, the company's president and co-founder, confirmed that it has noticed interference from Comcast, in addition to some Canadian Internet service providers.

    "They're using sophisticated technology to degrade service, which probably costs them a lot of money. It would be better to see them use that money to improve service," Navin said, noting that BitTorrent and other peer-to-peer applications are a major reason consumers sign up for broadband.

    BitTorrent Inc. announced Oct. 9 that it was teaming up with online video companies to use its technology to distribute legal content.

    Other companies that rely on peer-to-peer technology, and could be affected if Comcast decides to expand the range of applications it filters, include Internet TV service Joost, eBay Inc.'s Skype video-conferencing program and movie download appliance Vudu. There is no sign that Comcast is hampering those services.

    Comcast subscriber Robb Topolski, a former software quality engineer at Intel Corp., started noticing the interference when trying to upload with file-sharing programs Gnutella and eDonkey early this year.

    In August, Topolski began to see reports on Internet forum DSLreports.com from other Comcast users with the same problem. He now believes that his home town of Hillsboro, Ore., was a test market for the technology that was later widely applied in other Comcast service areas.

    Topolski agrees that Comcast has a right to manage its network and slow down traffic that affects other subscribers, but disapproves of their method.

    "By Comcast not acknowledging that they do this at all, there's no way to report any problems with it," Topolski said.

  2. #2
    Newbie fooligar may be famous one day fooligar may be famous one day
    Join Date
    Sep 2005
    Posts
    40
    Thanks
    0
    Thanked 9 Times in 1 Post

    Re: Comcast Blocks Internet Traffic

    Here's a copy of internal email sent out to all the customer service staff at the Maryland call center in regards to the way how to handle questions from customers regarding this BitTorrent matter.

    All,
    You may get customers who are contacting us with regard to several articles which were published recently, accusing Comcast of blocking or otherwise filtering customers' Internet traffic. An in-depth AP story suggests Comcast is hindering our customers' ability to use BitTorrent, a peer to peer file sharing program. If a customer contacts us to inquire about this, please use the following talking points.

    Comcast does not block access to any applications, including BitTorrent

    We respect our customers' privacy and we don't monitor specific customer activities on the Internet or track individual online behavior, such as which websites they visit. Therefore, we do not know whether any individual user is visiting BitTorrent or any other site...

    We have a responsibility to provide all of our customers with a good experience online and we use the latest technologies to manage our network. This is standard practice for ISPs and network operators all over the world.

    We rarely disclose our vendors or our processes for operating our network both for competitive reasons and to protect against network abuse.

    If a customer asks:
    I read that Comcast is limiting customer access to BitTorrent. Is this true?

    Respond:
    No. We do not block access to any applications, including BitTorrent. We also respect our customers' privacy and don't monitor specific customer activities on the Internet or track individual online behavior, such as which websites they visit. Therefore, we do not know whether any individual user is visiting BitTorrent or any other site.

    We have a responsibility to provide all of our customers with a good experience online and we use the latest technologies to manage our network. This is standard practice for ISPs and network operators all over the world.

    Are you working with Sandvine as these reports claim?

    Respond:
    We rarely disclose our vendors or our processes for operating our network both for competitive reasons and to protect against network abuse.

    Please do not deviate from the responses above. If you have any questions about this issue, please reach out to Brian Becker, Gene Bridges or myself.

    Thanx...
    ________________________________________
    Michael S. Groman
    Manager / IP Support
    MD-DE-RCH Region


    Source: Consumerist

  3. #3
    Commander Ham Chiefblackhammer is making a name for themselves Chiefblackhammer is making a name for themselves Chiefblackhammer is making a name for themselves Chiefblackhammer's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2004
    Location
    Winston Salem, NC
    Posts
    1,887
    Thanks
    4
    Thanked 84 Times in 68 Posts

    Re: Comcast Blocks Internet Traffic

    @fooligar. That doesn't address if program utilities such as BitTorrent are being interfered with, there is a big difference between "blocking" and "interfering" with. Basically it reads to me that they are trying to smooth things over by saying they aren't blocking the service but not addressing if it is true they are interfering with it. I doubt most internet savvy members would buy this claim by Comcast as it clearly is a diversionary tactic from the real merit of concern their users have.


  4. #4
    Grouchy Old Anime Otaku LenMiyata has become well known LenMiyata has become well known LenMiyata has become well known LenMiyata's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2005
    Location
    Silicon Valley, California
    Posts
    5,477
    Thanks
    0
    Thanked 172 Times in 147 Posts

    Re: Comcast Blocks Internet Traffic

    Grumble Grumble Grumble

    Also notice that the technical service guidelines say nothing about sending forged reset packets for BitTorrent connections, which effectively disconnects the connection...

    CNET News has a web page collecting together all of the the many news articles on the subject here... File-sharing furor for Comcast | CNET News.com
    FAVOURITE THREADS EXPLAIN why, or risk an infraction.
    Rantings of a Grouchy Old Anime Otaku

  5. #5
    Witch Hunter GallComp may be famous one day GallComp may be famous one day GallComp's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2004
    Location
    Near Disneyland
    Posts
    944
    Thanks
    2
    Thanked 19 Times in 16 Posts

    Re: Comcast Blocks Internet Traffic

    Comcast sued over Web interference - Yahoo! News

    Well the first Lawsuit has been made. I think more will folow...

  6. #6
    Otaku know1 may be famous one day know1 may be famous one day know1's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2005
    Location
    here
    Posts
    270
    Thanks
    0
    Thanked 5 Times in 4 Posts

    Re: Comcast Blocks Internet Traffic

    There are ways around this. Of the few I've seen, encryption seems to be the most viable, free and stable means. Comcast will have a harder time figuring out bit torrent connections from other traffic. Follow this link if you are having this issue:

    LINK

  7. #7
    Legendary Otaku Snake Champion, Zelda Champion, Crazy Koala Champion, Minigolf Champion, Concentrate Champion, Guess 5 Champion, Batting Champ Champion, Beach Ball Control Champion, Bookworm Champion, Wacky Word Wiz Champion, Fight Fight 3 Champion, Spinner's Luck Champion, Traffic Jam Champion, Yeti Pengu Throw Champion Legend is making a name for themselves Legend is making a name for themselves Legend is making a name for themselves Legend's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2004
    Location
    Sharks Territory
    Posts
    4,762
    Thanks
    64
    Thanked 67 Times in 61 Posts

    Re: Comcast Blocks Internet Traffic

    I'm glad someone is stepping up to sue them. Might not be as effective as doing all that encryption stuff, but still it is in the court of law and what's worse than a class action. Maybe I'm just bitter that charge me so damn much for so little channels.

    'Cause you give me something / That makes me scared, alright / This could be nothing / But I'm willing to give it a try / Please give me something
    'Cause someday I might call you from my heart

+ Reply to Thread

Similar Threads

  1. Comcast
    By Legend in forum Tech Center
    Replies: 13
    Last Post: Sep 08, 2007, 02:40 AM
  2. traffic
    By chrystalann2004 in forum Poems
    Replies: 5
    Last Post: Aug 02, 2007, 08:02 AM
  3. Blocks of Life
    By BlueFox1 in forum Poems
    Replies: 7
    Last Post: Jan 16, 2007, 11:58 AM
  4. Arist Blocks?
    By Creesco in forum Empire Clan Vault
    Replies: 4
    Last Post: Aug 14, 2006, 02:12 PM
  5. new 'On Demand' anime (comcast)
    By dharuko in forum The Thread Vault
    Replies: 8
    Last Post: Oct 14, 2005, 11:29 AM

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts