lostgirl

I wonder why so many people are asking themselves the same questions but don't dare to say them out loud. So many life experiences and for what?

The AO fora are great, I just had a look at the discussions. I have a new one.
Let's talk about what you consider good and bad deeds. What is right and what isn't? That is my question.
I can't wait to read the answers!

__________________

always happy..always optimist...just lost

Patrick Chan

hi lost - it depends on the mindset, no right or wrong deeds. Take for instance the mind of a suicide bomber, he/she thinks killing ownself and other innocent people was the right thing to do! so....

lostgirl

yes let's get that as an answer..but I asket about u guys...what do you consider god or bagg deed...don't get me wrong....cuz bad can be whatever you want to be bad...and the same goes for the right to......

__________________

always happy..always optimist...just lost

Patrick Chan

figure it'll be a darn long list to compile...usee...let me put it this way...when i do something that draws a smile, I'll consider that a good deed...but then the freakin devils also smiles for bad deeds done!. ithink its hard to draw a line on this

frr_Vegeta

Actually if you want to get into the mindset of a suicide bomber, the people you are killing aren't innocent.

__________________
' frr_Vegeta


Chaos...is the only true answer.

Hassun

Ooookaaaay, I'm going to try to clean that first post up a bit.

__________________

HolderOfTheDarkChalice

good and bad have infinet paradox's my self i veiw bad as something
i thing you do when you have more than one wya out and do the bad thing
anyway like suicude thats bad from view because thats never an option.

good on the other hand is something i see as something you do out of
respect or love for somone, or not caring if they won't it or not .

an example of both of these is abortion some see it as good because
they are saving the child this thought isnt used much but its one
idea of a good way to see it, the bad view is that the baby is a life and need's to be preserved .

there are just to many ways to lay clame to just one good way and bad way

__________________

Shu

good and bad depend on a persons mindset

some people think its wrong to be gay, others think it is right(just an ex.)

i think an example of wrong is murdering someone for no reason

Namida Goddess

If bad deeds did not exist then good ones wouldn't either. They define each other. It is human nature to be both good and bad because everyone has the choice. For every bad deed there is always a worse one. If someone committed two crimes one worse than the other would the lesser be considered a better deed. And then could it be called a good deed? If you kill an evil person is it a good deed. You have murdered which is a bad thing but you have rid the world of something terrible.

__________________

Patrick Chan

there you go vegeta...a one tracked mind adulterated and beyond comprehensiion

LenMiyata

Grumble Grumble Grumble
But vegata's point is still valid... Which does bring up another related topic of philosophy...

1. Do you believe in a Ultimate Good and a Ultimate Evil

Or

2. The concepts of Good and Bad are relative. You can't recognize something is good unless you can compare it to something that is bad, and make a decision on which is more desirable...

From your statement, it appears that you believe in #1, that something that is Good is always good, regardless of it's context. And something that is Bad, likewise, is always bad, even if it's used to accomplish Good ends...

__________________