Kool2bchilln

I think an anime should only be turned into a game if it has an element of game "built it" (so to speak)
For example, i think an internet-based computer game of the (dot)hack anime would be a very good game.

__________________
Inderagamono

LichGRIFFIN

__________________

Lenne

Yes and No!
there are good anime games... and there are bad anime games..
for example:
Dot Hack wasn't all that bad! in facted I liked them
Initial D I have this game for PS2! great game
Naruto some of the Naruto games aren't that bad!
FMA great anime series... crap game...

I think if they are gonna put the time and effort into it then yes....

__________________

AtheniaOnline, FFrepublic, AnimeOnline, soompi, solid07, Anipike.... Same Lenne

NeoDeath90

depends on the anime, its fanbase, and how cheaply/easily the game can be made.

many animes are turned into mediocre games because it is a quick cash influx. we all know that hardcore naruto fans bout all the naruto:ultimate ninja games. (you know who you are)

many times because of the shows popularity, games are made. these games have massive amounts of flaws and sometimes arent even that fun to play.

so to answer the question, yes, animes should become games ONLY IF the company that has agreed to make it is reputable and popular, the game has redeeming characteristics that outweigh flaws, and the game is actually fun!

__________________
Thank you, Yasmine, for this badass sig!

ron119125

Just because there have been some poor anime based games does not mean they should stop trying. Dot hack was a very good game in my opion and I think One Piece colud be made into a great fighting or RPG.

gamemaster331

I, for one, would like to see some of my favorite animes become games. Granted there have been some lousy games made from animes and vice versa, but we never know which ones would be good and which ones wouldn't if the companies had never made them in the first place.

NeoDeath90

one piece was made into a fighting game. and it was god awful.

just because the anime is popular, doesn't mean there should be a game made out of it. i'll admit, there are exceptions (DBZ Budokai 3 and the Dot Hack series) but really, there should only be games if effort is put into them.

__________________
Thank you, Yasmine, for this badass sig!

Hantei16

You think they're bad don't you?..

Not impressed by anime based games?

For me there's nothing wrong with anime being turned into a game and vice-versa. There's a couple of bad renditions out there but as far as i know it there are a ton of good anime games, think about the Jump games, the SRWs, Ashita no Joe, Dynasty Warriors: Gundam, and the list goes on..If some of you haven't really had the chance to get your hands on such good games, then think again. Excellent anime games exist. A lot of games are exclusive only to Japan, those games hardly even reach the countries closest to Japan so unless it's a direct purchase or something illegal you're not going to get one...yeah if you're extremely lucky, you might.

Another thing, regional preferences. I've mentioned this already on another thread, and i'm not talking about USA and Japan alone. The taste of the east is diff'rent from the west's, most if not all the anime based games are made in Japan and those games might've been made to appeal to their audience.

The east have a much more heavier fanbase by numbers and by sheer dedication when it comes to anime especially the Japanese. Because an anime is so popular, the fans, by sheer dedication alone will bite almost everything related to it. Some anime are so popular in the east, so popular to the point that it dictates trends in pop culture, fashion, gaming, etc.. Because of this, people will play an anime based game because of the bandwagon, because it's uncool not to. We all know how far a dedicated fan can go, a dedicated fan will take all the negativity in the game for granted because of his devotion to the anime. Let's face it, a lot of people PLAY IN THE NAME OF THE NAME, not IN THE NAME OF THE GAME.

There's a lot of other reasons why most anime games are less appreciated: Language barrier, the game being unfaithful to the anime, the game being not as good as *insert an oh-so-great game here*(comparison issues), yadda yadda....

rematche

hellz yeah...see the result for yourself.
click here.
and i dare anyone who disagree with this.

__________________