Thread: Fullmetal vs. Mustang

Originally Posted by Namida Goddess

If the fight between Ed can Mustang wasn't ended early who do you think would have won? I think Mustang because of his experience in battle and his strength. Despite Ed's urge to win and his heart I still think that he would have lost.

I think ed would have won because the main character always wins but, roy has more battle experiance so im sure who would win but, id put my money on ed

Originally Posted by Hassun

And why are you people continuing to discuss this? Mustang beat clearly won in the manga and the only reason he didn't win in the anime is because he stopped at the last second (just before he was going to fry Edward) because he saw his war crimes flash before his eyes.

1) The reason people discuss this topic is because it is fun to.

2) Ed would have won because Roy hesitated and, hesitation leads to destruction isn't it obvious?

Roy. There is no question. Ed is just a child compared to him. Roy has much more experience in fighting than Ed does. Yes, ed is a state alchemist with a stubborn personality and strong will, but reality gets the best out of most of us. And reality is Roy'd win.

Yay, go Mustang!

I think that they would have worn them selves out and still cept going at it until one of them couldnt work anymore and then the other would take their chance. Personally I think Mustang would have annoued Ed so much that he would erupt and take charge at Mustang and beat him. Ed has so much anger in him that it would become energy.

I have to agree that Mustang would win. He is a skilled manipulator of

emotions and Ed can't fight that because he's too emotional. Besides, Mustang has experienced a lot of years worth of killing and fighting.

Mustang will probably the one who'll gonna win.... Uhm... but in someway ed have a little chance of winning... But try to see the experience... Mustang will win...

definitly Mustang. hes definitly no noob. (at the time, ed was a noob)