Thread: Fullmetal vs. Mustang

Originally Posted by Akura13

Edward of coarse! Have any of you seen the people and hamunculie Ed defeated?? Like the "indestructable" Greed? Ed defeated him! So I definatly think Ed would have won!

I'd just like to thank you, apparrently someone else has seen Ed fight

Originally Posted by Lupas

I'd just like to thank you, apparrently someone else has seen Ed fight

And the point you're making is...?

Mustang would definately win... I pesonaly think ED is more talented than mustang.... but i dont think anyone can beat Mutang's fire alchemy....... And we shouldnt also forget about Mustang's great military experience ..

oh i think ED would win...he has alot of bravere...and he has the will to go on..not to mention he can use alchemy without a circle..but hen again Mustang has that circle on his glove...

Originally Posted by fayt lingod

i think mustang would have won. accually there's not a doubt in my mind. his alchemy is more deadly and much faster then Ed's and he has much more experience. Ed fights with too much emotion, call him short and he goes berserk. tahts why i think Roy would win.

I agree with you 100%
cause Roy is much better in fights than Ed ( who entered the military world to find the Philosopher stone to help his brother ... not to be a good fighter) ...

Originally Posted by maamon

I agree with you 100%
cause Roy is much better in fights than Ed ( who entered the military world to find the Philosopher stone to help his brother ... not to be a good fighter) ...

Why are people talking like this fight never ended? It did, and Ed clearly won. It may not have been under the right cirumstances, but Roy lost when he had the flash back. Simple, done, end.

A lot of battles end like that. It may not be the most honorable, skill determining, or spectacular battle, but 1 man would be left standing and that man would clearly be ED. You blink you lose, very simple logic.

Now if it were another battle, same time, no mock, and Roy didn't have his flashbacks and everything was done the right way, Roy would obviously be the winner. Ed did not have the experience he had at the end of the series, nor did he have the knowledge of his opponent. Roy, had the experience, the knowledge, the first strike, and surprise on his side.

That isn't much of a comparison. The only way ED had a chance within the first 20 seconds was because he ran behind people like a coward. Now I understand that obstacles and terrain are a main facotry when in war, but on a flat open surface, it is clear that ED would stand absolutely no chance.

Originally Posted by Tbaism

Why are people talking like this fight never ended? It did, and Ed clearly won. It may not have been under the right cirumstances, but Roy lost when he had the flash back. Simple, done, end.

A lot of battles end like that. It may not be the most honorable, skill determining, or spectacular battle, but 1 man would be left standing and that man would clearly be ED. You blink you lose, very simple logic.

Now if it were another battle, same time, no mock, and Roy didn't have his flashbacks and everything was done the right way, Roy would obviously be the winner. Ed did not have the experience he had at the end of the series, nor did he have the knowledge of his opponent. Roy, had the experience, the knowledge, the first strike, and surprise on his side.

That isn't much of a comparison. The only way ED had a chance within the first 20 seconds was because he ran behind people like a coward. Now I understand that obstacles and terrain are a main facotry when in war, but on a flat open surface, it is clear that ED would stand absolutely no chance.

Roy won in the manga version. He didn't have the flashback and zapped Edward.
And by your logic nobody actually won. Not Roy and not Edward either.