Xelhes

wow ya know i never thought about that wow thats a smack in the face ur right the gate wasnt destryoed bc it the source of all alchemy so whats stopping them for goin back to there world i mean if they can do it agin the ending should have went like this

Ed goes back to destroy the bridge to both worlds then goes back trhough the gate when al and winry and everyone else thinks hes gone for good he appers and the end some little chitter chat and the end thats a perfect one winry and ed can become a item al has his brother back and al has his original body and ed can continue to be the full metal alchemist...

__________________

Arrianna

That is exactly the same problem I had with it. The end only made sense if they were planning on making another movie or a new series but... they say they're not. Someone deserves to be slapped.

__________________

l Stone Hold l Now We're Cooking! l

Xelhes

lol yea u tell em whast what they need to serious extend the series after only 50 episdoes come on lets b real thats no where near enough

__________________

Chiefblackhammer

I disagree...it was a perfectly good series but in fact it may have been too long...there were a lot of filler type of eps in there. If they just used the eps that really built the story it would only be a 26 eps series. I just think they ended it poorly.

__________________

Xelhes

and i dissagree with you the series needeed to be longer than 52 episodes thats not long enough i enjoyed it but there could have been room for more

__________________

Chiefblackhammer

When you draw a series out like that it just takes away from it's greatness too much...take Dragon Ball & Inu-Yasha...they had way too many episodes that were just fillers...the same would happen with FMA...they would run out of stuff to actually build the story and just show a bunch of filler crap....sure everyone would love to see an endless amount of episodes on a series that they love...doesn't mean that is always the best way to do it...or that it will make the series better.

__________________

deodaclan18

The series was fine the way it was, there is no need for it to be longer, but the movied just ruined it for me.

Xelhes

the movie could have been way better and i mean ED NEVER GOT HIS LIMBS BACK wrath still has them and i have a question remeber in the final episode when al died to get ed his arm and leg back well wrath still had them ? that is odd but then y did he loose them agin to get al back i dont get that part well the movie ruined it all fo rme

__________________

Chiefblackhammer

First off in the movie wrath is missing those limbs as it clearly shows that and Winry offered to fix his automail. Now Ed got them back when Al brought him back to life...however when Ed brought Al back he gave up his limbs again and passed through the gate...that was the end to the series.

__________________

Xelhes

but why did he have to give up his limbs if he had the philosphers stone then he didnt need equevelncy

__________________

Chiefblackhammer

Al used the philosophers stone completely up to bring Ed back...thus Ed had to give something up when he brought Al back.

__________________