Hassun

No, getting pregnant isn't necessarily related to rape.

__________________

!The White Wolf

WHY must you be so difficult on such matters, when the evidence is righ there!

She gets captured by the military.. held hostage for about a year.. and ends up coming out with a baby.. no father for the child or anything of the sort.

Hassun

So how do you know it was Hakuro who raped her? And can't she have just fallen in love and had a baby with some random military dude?
I know it's sensible to think she was raped (people tend to go mute after horrific treatment) but the proof isn't there.

My main problem with your theory is the Hakuro part.

__________________

!The White Wolf

Information:

Here

and

Here

He might not have been the one who raped her.. but he was responsible for it.. and he did have something to with it.

Hassun

When I say sources I don't mean fan sites.

__________________

!The White Wolf

It is all implied. No, Hiromu Arakawa may not have showed us that Hakuro was responsible for Rose's rape.. but it is all implied. And it hints strongly towards the worst. If enough fan sites are talking about the same situation.. obviously it is what most likely happened behind the scenes, seeing as how everyone who watches the show thinks so. As for actual facts. I suggest you have a chat with the creator of it all.

Hassun

You say Hiromu Arakawa but you might find it interesting to know that she didn't create the anime at all. In fact, the manga creator almost never supervises the creation of the anime. They just give permission to make the anime to someone else.


So there you have it "full blooded virgen 666" (funny name btw).

Winry wasn't raped at all.
Rose/Rosé might have been raped, although substantial evidence is lacking at best.






P.S. We're only talking about the anime here, not the manga

__________________

Kisa Elric

...Wow... white wolf, I have to give you my props. You certinaly are devoted to the wonderful anime of Fullmetal Alchemist! And Hassun, she's right, Rose was kidnapped by the military and raped by a soldier/officer. Although it does not give definite proof that it was Hakuro ( and I don't believe it -he seems to be a family man) it could be possible. Believe me. I am a FMA Otaku and this argument is getting nowhere! So I'm not on anyone's side really.