Thread: Rurouni Kenshin (anime vs manga ending)

I actually think both the manga and the anime have lackluster last story arcs. The anime one is just plain horrible, an exemplary case of the "anime caught up with the manga" syndrome. So the anime creators had to make up a whole arc and they ended up with the incredibly awful Shimabara one.

The manga on the other hand, clearly meant to tie up the loose endings in the story. Most prominently the origin of the X shaped scar. It starts out very awesomely with the past chapters but the end battles and the 'Sanosuke's family' story left a lot to be desired as far as I'm concerned. I actually think Watsuki sensei grew tired of the series and wanted to pursue other projects.

I didn't like the change in drawing style either. It really reached a high point during the (equally sublime) Kyoto arc of the manga. Actually I guess that's my opinion on the entire story, both in art and storytelling the manga reached incredible heights during the Kyoto arc but the parts before and after it couldn't match it.

Which doesn't mean I look down on it, it's pretty much the best samurai fighting manga I have ever read and I gladly bought every volume. It just leaves me with that feeling that it could have been one of the best manga ever but just fell short in the end.

Originally Posted by Hassun

It starts out very awesomely with the past chapters but the end battles and the 'Sanosuke's family' story left a lot to be desired as far as I'm concerned.

Personally, I would've preferred it if Sanosuke's story was left out. It could've been a filler arc for all that it's worth.

Originally Posted by Hassun

Which doesn't mean I look down on it, it's pretty much the best samurai fighting manga I have ever read and I gladly bought every volume. It just leaves me with that feeling that it could have been one of the best manga ever but just fell short in the end.

Definitely! I'm especially thrilled with the many historical connections drawn, and the many references to actual historical events (even though it's mostly been warped to fit into the fiction genre). That was the main appeal to the storyline for me, but I guess that's where the appeal is lost for many. No one seems to want to watch a "historical anime", and the fact that it's more than a decade old does little to draw new fans. A shame really. Despite its flaws, it really is a great series.

I usually like it when reality and fiction get blended together like that. And also how the characters' abilities are extraordinary yet not blatantly supernatural as in Dragonball (flying, shooting energy beams, etc.) for example. Stories like this are one of the best ways for young people to get interested in history in my opinion. I understand that many teenagers today have a certain aversion to the subject while it is one of the most important ones of all.

Originally Posted by Hassun

I usually like it when reality and fiction get blended together like that. And also how the characters' abilities are extraordinary yet not blatantly supernatural as in Dragonball (flying, shooting energy beams, etc.) for example.

Haha yeah, Dragonball Z was definitely an overkill. It's never really caught my interest before. I'd prefer some logic behind their abilities.

Originally Posted by Hassun

Stories like this are one of the best ways for young people to get interested in history in my opinion. I understand that many teenagers today have a certain aversion to the subject while it is one of the most important ones of all.

You're spot on there. It was only through the Rurouni Kenshin series that I began avidly reading up on Japanese history. Many people seem to think that because history is no longer valid to us today, it's not important and therefore not necessary to learn about. I'll admit that I used to hold that viewpoint as well, until I studied World War I intensively in my modern history course. I'm now a fan of all WWI-related films and novels. "War on the Western Front" is currently on my top films/novels list. The details are truly fascinating. I'm a little miffed that my course doesn't cover WWII as well, but I'll get to that somehow.

Speaking of which, I have yet to see that film, The Last Samurai, starring Tom Cruise. I've been meaning to see it for awhile now, but for some reason, having a caucasian lead in a samurai film is a little unappealing.

Originally Posted by mystical shadow angel

You're spot on there. It was only through the Rurouni Kenshin series that I began avidly reading up on Japanese history. Many people seem to think that because history is no longer valid to us today, it's not important and therefore not necessary to learn about. I'll admit that I used to hold that viewpoint as well, until I studied World War I intensively in my modern history course. I'm now a fan of all WWI-related films and novels. "War on the Western Front" is currently on my top films/novels list. The details are truly fascinating. I'm a little miffed that my course doesn't cover WWII as well, but I'll get to that somehow.

Speaking of which, I have yet to see that film, The Last Samurai, starring Tom Cruise. I've been meaning to see it for awhile now, but for some reason, having a caucasian lead in a samurai film is a little unappealing.

I am a history major at my college and I am taking world history, and so far all I am learning about is more western than eastern civilizations, this is a shame because their is more history out their to learn about in the world than european history. but it is refreshing to see that I am not the only one who seeks more about history than what is in the textbook. I watched the anime and enjoyed (I saw it on Toonami and it ended at the end of the Kyoto arc.) what I had seen, but the Manga was so much better, because it got right to the point, it did not have a beach scene (bikini's, etc.)or any fillerific arc's, it just answers the questions and why Sanosuke had to leave on his one path (not to mention to get out of dodge as that saying goes), but if I had to choose between the two, I will pick the manga over the anime because it keeps the momentum of the story to an end and end's just right.

ps. The Last Samurai is a good movie, however the title of the movie can be misleading, which is why when you watch the movie you think why is Tom Cruise the "last samurai", so if you do watch it forget about the title, otherwise you will think that it is little big horn, japanese style.

i actually overall perfer the manga, because it gives off more of a historical feel. it's more detailed, easier to comprehend..
the anime was harder to understand, it takes longer to read it all.

Grumble Grumble Grumble

To quote the Forum Rules...

Inactive threads, which have not been posted in for 1 month or more, should not be revived. They are considered dead.

Please read the Forum Rules located here... Anime Online - FAQ: GENERAL RULES:

Closing...