I liked fueledpunk69 due to clean design and no clutter and noise on the signature. I think we can sometimes overdo signatures by placing too many layers onto the image.
The layout and images for equinn was good, but the text font let it down. Rather than a V.S text in the middle, perhaps an image of a gun / dripping blood or something war type would have been more suitable.
The best fighting images were by Naruto1988, but there was too much noise and clutter overall around these characters.